Can my insurance company force me to use their preferred body shop in Ontario?

No. Ontario law is clear: only the vehicle owner has the right to select the repair shop. Steering customers to preferred shops is illegal.

Why does my insurance company say they won't guarantee repairs at your shop?

This is a fear tactic. Their guarantee protects the insurer's costs, not your vehicle's quality. Pro Auto Body provides its own written Lifetime Warranty — stronger protection for you.

Should I call my insurance company or Pro Auto Body first?

Call us first. We guide you through what to say so your rights are protected from the very first conversation with your insurer.

Ontario Consumer Protection Act

Your Insurer Has
No Right to Choose.

⚖️

Ontario law prohibits any insurance company from requiring you to repair at a specific body shop. Only you — the vehicle owner — have that right.

Read the law — Ontario.ca →

When your car is damaged, your insurer will try to send you to their contracted shops. They may threaten that repairs elsewhere won't be guaranteed. This is a tactic — not the truth. Call us first. We handle everything.

📞 Call Us Before Your Insurer

📍 Bring Your Car In

★★★★★ 4.9 · 731 Google Reviews · Free assessment · Mon–Fri 8AM–5PM

⚖️

Ontario Law Is on Your Side

Forcing you to their shop is illegal. Period.

📋

We Handle the Adjuster for You

Estimates, supplements, approvals — fully managed

🛡️

Our Warranty Beats Theirs

Written Lifetime Warranty — stronger than any insurer "guarantee"

⭐

4.9★ · 731 Google Reviews · BBB A+

No insurance contracts. Loyal only to you.

What They Tell You — and the Truth

Insurance Adjusters Are Trained to Say These Things

Every line is designed to steer you toward their contracted shops. Here's what they say — and what Ontario law actually says.

❌ Adjuster says

"If you don't use our shop, we won't guarantee the work."

✅ The truth

Their "guarantee" protects their cost budget — not your car. Pro Auto Body's written Lifetime Warranty is stronger, independent protection that no insurer can cancel.

❌ Adjuster says

"Going to another shop will delay your claim."

✅ The truth

Insurers are legally required to process your claim regardless of shop choice. We manage the entire process — there are no delays on your end.

❌ Adjuster says

"You may pay more out of pocket at a non-preferred shop."

✅ The truth

You pay only your deductible — set by your policy, not your shop choice. Once your estimate is approved, the insurer pays the rest. Full stop.

❌ Adjuster says

"Our preferred shops use the best parts and meet our standards."

✅ The truth

DRP shops agree to use cheaper aftermarket parts and lower labour rates to keep the insurer's costs down. Their loyalty is to the insurer — not to your vehicle's quality.

The Right Order

Call Us First — Before You Call Your Insurer

One phone call to us before you report the claim protects all your rights from the very first conversation.

Call Pro Auto Body First

We tell you exactly what to say to your insurer so you don't accidentally waive your rights. We help you get your claim number correctly.

⚠️ Don't call insurer first

We Handle the Adjuster

Bring your car in. We arrange the inspection, write the estimate, fight every supplement, and get full approval. You don't speak to the adjuster.

✓ Zero paperwork for you

Repair. Direct Billing.

Factory-spec repair with PPG Envirobase® HP paint. We bill your insurer directly. You pay only your deductible. Lifetime Warranty included.

✓ We bill insurance directly

Your Questions Answered

What North York Drivers Ask After a Collision

No. Ontario law is unambiguous: only the vehicle owner has the right to select the repair shop. If your adjuster tells you otherwise, they are using an illegal pressure tactic called "steering." You can refuse firmly and professionally.

What to say: "I am exercising my right under the Ontario Consumer Protection Act to have my vehicle repaired at Pro Auto Body Shop, 73 Alness St Unit 1, North York. Please arrange for your appraiser to inspect the vehicle at their facility."

The insurer's "guarantee" at their preferred shops is a risk management tool — it protects the insurer's cost exposure, not the quality of your repair. DRP shops agree to use cheaper parts and faster turnarounds to stay on the preferred list. When there is a conflict between you and the insurer, which side do you think their contracted shop is on?

Pro Auto Body's Lifetime Warranty is issued by us directly — to you. If the paint peels, fades, or any workmanship fails, we fix it free. No insurer involvement. No conditions.

Simple test: Ask your insurer to put their "guarantee" in writing, specifying exactly what defects they will cover and for how long. They will not. We put ours in writing on every repair order.

Once the insurer approves our estimate, they pay the approved amount. You pay only your deductible — the same amount you would pay at their preferred shop. If supplemental repairs are discovered during teardown, we negotiate those directly with the adjuster. You are not responsible for supplements.

In 20+ years of handling claims in North York, no client's claim has ever been legitimately delayed because they chose us. Insurers are legally required to process valid claims regardless of shop choice. If an adjuster creates unnecessary delays as a pressure tactic, we advise you on how to escalate to the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRAO).

★★★★★